Apr 302013
 

Duncan and Gemma return in Deborah Crombie’s The Sound of Broken Glass (sounds similar to A City of Broken Glass by Rebecca Cantrell, but no relation), the fifteenth book in the series.

Gemma takes the lead in this one; her husband, Duncan Kincaid, is on family leave, caring for their adopted child, Charlotte, who continues to have trouble adjusting and can’t handle being left at preschool on her own. Gemma’s new position as detective chief inspector puts her in charge of an investigation into the murder of a barrister, whose body is found in a seedy hotel, tied up and strangled on the bed. During the investigation, Gemma’s assistant, DI Melody Talbott (whose father owns a popular tabloid newspaper and who’s a lot wealthier than you or me), falls for a guitar player, and Duncan helps investigate on the side by talking to friends in the business. But then, a second barrister is killed in similar circumstances, and the team must figure out the connection between the victims.

The setting, the Crystal Palace area of London, has historical roots that are described in brief introductory quotes at the beginning of each chapter. Since I’d never even heard of the Crystal Palace, this was an interesting side story that begins with the London Exhibition in 1851 and ends with its destruction by fire in 1936.

This time it’s Duncan’s turn to face a life change. At the end of the book, once Gemma and her team have wrapped up the murder investigation and saved a life or two, Duncan has also solved Charlotte’s daycare problem and heads eagerly back to work. And what he finds is not at all what he expected.

Share
Jul 162012
 

I’m a longtime fan of Deborah Crombie’s Duncan Kincaid and Gemma James series, but I struggled with No Mark Upon Her.

A couple of things slowed me down. First, there’s a lot about rowing; the victim, a Met police officer named Rebecca Meredith, is a rower killed while out on her boat, so many of the witnesses are experts and talk about things like The Boat Race (evidently, there’s only really one, an annual Oxford vs. Cambridge event on the Thames) and blue boats. Not only don’t I know anything about this, but I don’t care. It must be what many Brits think when hearing about the American Super Bowl — whatever! These details are not at all peripheral to the story, so you can’t even really skim over them.

Leaving aside my own sports biases, I think the story also suffers from the boring place where Duncan and Gemma’s relationship stands right now. They’ve taken in a child whose parent was killed in an earlier book, and the girl demands much of their attention, so that an inordinate amount of time is spent caring for, worrying about and otherwise balancing her needs with those of the other children, Kit and Toby. Not that I don’t have sympathy for little Charlotte, it’s just that there’s not much excitement in the family life to counteract the basically uninteresting (to me) rowing storyline.

All of this makes it sound like I hated the book. Not actually! I’ve just enjoyed this series so much in the past that this somewhat weaker entry didn’t quite meet my expectations. I did like the storyline involving two dog handlers, Kieran and Tavie, who work on the search and rescue team that finds Becca’s body. Kieran is a Gulf War veteran struggling with the aftereffects of war, both physical and mental, and his challenges added some depth to this story. Moreover, Gemma’s career path takes a turn at the end of the book that promises some interesting developments in this series.

Share
Seo PackagesBlog Comment ServicesGov Backlinks
Better Tag Cloud